MEPO Forum :: 黑格爾哲學

boris Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I have to admit questions I posted a year ago were
> not right questions.  A thinker or a philosopher
> asking right questions will be a good start.
> 1.  what is the main argument Hegel repudiated
> Kant's subject/object?
> Not an important problem, the right question might
> be "what is the difference between Kant's
> transcendental unity of apperception  and Hegel's
> consciousness?"
> 2. Kant's phenomenal and noumenonal world
> separation
> Question should be "How does Hegel accept Kant's
> phenomenal and noumenonal world separation?" Does
> Hegel deny the existence of noumenonal world? or
> rather redefine the noumenonal world within the
> realm of consciousness? Hegel just set aside the
> ontological question of  the noumenonal world (my
> understanding).
> 3. What is the absolute knowing?
> Is it an epidemiological question to Hegel?  Does
> the "absolute" ever stop to morphing itself?
> 4. "no place for god in Hegelian dialectic" 
> Wrong conception I believe. The question should be
> "What is the god meant to Hegel?"
> Is the god an instrumental god to Hegel? Is the
> god an instrumental god to Kant? Kant needs an
> instrumental god to synthesize his theoretical
> reason and practical reason, but Hegel does not
> need an instrumental god for that purpose. Why? 
> Then what is Hegel's ethics or morality? How does
> Hegel deal with Kant's morality? That is Kant's
> powerful transcendental deduction from law of
> non-contradiction to categorical imperative
> (Kantian morality)